McClintock's Essay


Toward a Place for Study in a World of Instruction

Robbie McClintock

Institute for Learning Technologies
Teachers College — Columbia University
December 2000


   PDF version of the document (Get help printing this file)

   Print version



Author's note to the electronic version:
This essay originally appeared in the Teachers College Record, 73:2, December 1971, pp. 161-205. I wrote it in late 1970 and early 1971, with generous support from the Carnegie Corporation. Throughout the essay, I used "man" and associated masculine pronouns consistently in a generic sense to include both genders. Were I to rewrite the essay, I would change the usage, along with much else. The electronic version reproduces the essay unchanged, however, except to convert it to Device Independent Format for citation by paragraphs rather than by page numbers. Subsequent technologicial innovation has, of course, rendered my 20th-century examples obsolete. Nevertheless, more than anything I could envision in 1970, digital technologies are now providing educators and students with tools of study, as opposed to tools of instruction. As a result, the following reflections may have some continuing relevance in 21st-century efforts to transform education practice.

Table of Contents

Introduction  
Introduction 
Section 1 
Study as Education 
Section 2 
After Plato 
Section 3 
Trivial Teachers 
Section 4 
A World of Instruction 
Section 5 
Dropouts 
Section 6 
Study Schools for Children 
Section 7 
Apprentice Schools 
Section 8 
An Encyclopedia of Study 
Section 9 
Language Study with Television 
Section 10 
The Future 
Section 11 
Infinite Possibilities